Guidelines for Authors

1. Requirements for design and procedure for submitting a publication

The editorial office of «Visnyk of the Lviv University. Series Physics» accepts original, unpublished materials. The maximum article size is 20 pages. All articles must correspond to Provisional regulations for publishing articles at Lviv University.

Articles are printed in Ukrainian (with an expanded English abstract of at least 1800 characters, including keywords) or in English (with an expanded Ukrainian abstract of at least 1800 characters, including keywords). Article references should be accompanied by a DOI. In addition to the list made by ДСТУ 8203:2015, a bibliography should be duplicated in English, and a separate list of «References» should be issued according to the AIP standard. An example of an article design and style file is zrazok.zip. The drawing files (.eps, .tiff, .pdf, etc.) must have at least 300 dpi resolution.

It is needed to submit:

  • an electronic version of the article in LaTeX format to visnyk.lnu@gmail.com;
  • contact details of the responsible author: email, telephone, mailing address.

The articles are noticed by two reviewers.

Authors (including co-authors) are restricted to publishing no more than one article per single issue of the journal.

 

2. Peer Review Process

Peer review (expert evaluation) is a cornerstone of the editorial process, aimed at ensuring the high scientific quality of the journal’s publications. Its purpose is to select rigorous manuscripts and provide an objective assessment of their scientific novelty, reliability, and compliance with academic, ethical, and publishing standards. All reviewers are committed to the principles of impartiality, confidentiality, and the norms of publication ethics.

Review Model

The journal employs a double-blind peer review model: both authors and reviewers remain anonymous to each other throughout the process.

Editorial Workflow

  • Initial Screening: All submitted manuscripts undergo a technical check for compliance with formatting requirements, thematic scope, and copyright standards.
  • Preliminary Assessment: The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized member of the Editorial Board conducts an initial scientific evaluation. In the event of a potential conflict of interest, the responsible individual recuses themselves from the review process.
  • Expert Evaluation: Following the initial screening, the anonymized manuscript is assigned to at least two independent experts: a member of the Editorial Board specialized in the relevant field and an external reviewer (national or international expert). Reviewers must have no affiliations with the authors or their institutions and must be free from any conflicts of interest.

Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on:

  • Alignment of the title with the article content;
  • Relevance and scientific novelty of the research;
  • Validity and soundness of the results;
  • Practical significance and overall scientific value.

Review Outcomes

Based on the evaluation, the reviewer provides one of the following recommendations:

  • Accept: The manuscript is suitable for publication in its current form.
  • Minor Revision: The manuscript requires slight adjustments.
  • Major Revision: The manuscript requires significant changes and potentially a second round of review.
  • Reject: The manuscript is not suitable for publication.

In the case of a negative decision or a request for revisions, the reviewer must provide reasoned comments. All review reports are archived by the Editorial Office for a mandatory period.

Decision-making and Timelines

Authors receive the editorial decision along with the reviewers’ comments (anonymized). While authors are encouraged to address the reviewers’ suggestions, fulfilling these recommendations does not guarantee final acceptance.

The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on publication based on the review reports and the manuscript’s overall compliance with journal requirements. If the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, an authorized member of the Editorial Board assumes responsibility for the final decision.

  • Standard Review Time: 2–4 weeks.
  • Average Time to First Decision: 4–8 weeks.

 

3. Complaints Procedure

The Editorial Board of the journal adheres to the principles of academic integrity and international standards of publication ethics, specifically the recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). This complaints procedure applies to authors of manuscripts and published articles, reviewers, members of the editorial board, and other parties involved in the publication process.

Complaints may be submitted by authors, reviewers, readers, institutional representatives, or any other interested parties. Submissions must be clear, well-founded, and contain sufficient facts or evidence of potential misconduct (including plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, improper authorship, redundant/duplicate submission, conflicts of interest, breaches in the peer review process, etc.).

Submission Requirements

A complaint must be submitted in written (electronic) form and should include:

  • Information about the complainant.
  • A detailed description of the alleged misconduct.
  • Data regarding the relevant manuscript or publication.
  • Supporting materials and evidence.

Complaints submitted in an abusive, threatening, or defamatory manner will not be considered. In cases falling outside the journal’s competence, the complainant will be provided with an appropriate reasoned explanation.

Investigation Process

Upon receipt of a complaint, the Editorial Office conducts a preliminary assessment. If there are grounds for a detailed investigation, the Editor-in-Chief forms an ad hoc committee consisting of Editorial Board members and/or independent experts, ensuring impartiality and the absence of conflicts of interest.

The Committee is authorized to:

  • Request explanations and documentation from all parties involved.
  • Consult external specialists.
  • Utilize specialized tools (such as plagiarism detection software) and other analytical resources.

The person against whom the complaint is filed has the right to be informed of its content, provide written explanations and additional materials, and appeal the decision in accordance with established procedures. The complainant, in turn, has the right to receive updates on the progress of the investigation and provide further evidence.

Decision and Outcomes

The final decision is made by the Editorial Board or the Editor-in-Chief based on the gathered materials. Depending on the nature of the violation, the following measures may be taken:

  • Publication of corrections (errata) or clarifications;
  • Retraction of the article;
  • Rejection of the manuscript;
  • Temporary suspension of the right to submit future materials;
  • Other appropriate actions as deemed necessary.

In cases of serious misconduct, materials may be forwarded to relevant institutions or competent authorities. All decisions are documented, all parties are notified of the outcomes, and confidentiality and personal data protection are guaranteed.

Timeline

Complaints should be sent to the editorial email address. The standard review period is up to 30 working days, with the possibility of an extension depending on the complexity of the case. All decisions are finalized in writing, and the parties are formally notified of the results.

 

4. Retraction and Correction Policy

The journal adheres to the principles of academic integrity and international standards of publication ethics, specifically the COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) guidelines, ensuring rigorous oversight of the originality of scientific materials. Any manifestations of research misconduct, including plagiarism, redundant (duplicate) publication, citation manipulation, data falsification or fabrication, and other violations, are grounds for editorial action.

Authors are required to submit only original manuscripts that are not under consideration by other publications. Failure to comply with these requirements—including simultaneous submission or duplication of research results—may lead to manuscript rejection or the imposition of sanctions. In cases where unethical practices are identified, the journal conducts an investigation in accordance with COPE procedures, providing authors with the opportunity to offer explanations.

Corrections, Errata, and Corrigenda

Depending on the nature of the error or violation, the Editorial Board may implement the following measures:

  • Correction: Published when inaccuracies are identified that do not undermine the core scientific findings.
  • Erratum: Issued for significant errors introduced by the editorial or production process.
  • Corrigendum: Issued for substantial errors made by the authors.

Corrections may be initiated by authors, editors, or readers. They undergo editorial review and are published as distinct documents linked to the original article.

Retraction of Published Articles

In cases of serious misconduct or fundamental errors, the Editorial Board may decide to retract an article. Grounds for retraction include, but are not limited to:

  • Unreliable results (due to major error or intentional misconduct);
  • Plagiarism or redundant/duplicate publication;
  • Data or image manipulation;
  • Authorship disputes or compromised peer review process;
  • Unethical research practices.

The decision to retract is made by the Editor-in-Chief following an investigation, which may involve independent experts. Once retracted, the article is clearly marked as “Retracted.” A formal retraction notice with a unique DOI is published, while the original material remains accessible but prominently watermarked to maintain the integrity of the permanent scientific record.

Expressions of Concern

If there are well-founded suspicions but insufficient evidence for immediate retraction, the Editorial Board may publish an Expression of Concern. This notice accompanies the article until the investigation is finalized. All editorial decisions are made as promptly as possible to ensure the integrity of the scholarly record.

Manuscript Withdrawal

Authors may request to withdraw their manuscript at any stage prior to publication. To do so, a formal written request stating the reasons for withdrawal must be submitted and signed by all co-authors. Upon approval, the manuscript is removed from the editorial process, and all copyrights remain with the authors.

 

5. Payment information

As a Diamond Open Access journal, we do not charge any submission or article processing charges (APCs). All publications are free for authors to publish and free for readers to access.